Build vs Buy Decisions

A structured framework for build, buy, partner or open source decisions: differentiation, total cost of ownership, time to market, risk, lock-in and exit costs.

Executive explanation

Build where software creates competitive advantage; buy (or use SaaS/open source) where it is a commodity. The hard part is honest assessment of differentiation and full lifecycle cost: building is not a one-time cost, and buying is not free of integration and lock-in costs.

Business scenario

A fintech needs (a) a card issuing processor, (b) a fraud detection system, (c) an HR system, and (d) a lending decision engine that is its core product.

Decision framework

Criterion Build favoured when Buy favoured when
Differentiation Core to competitive advantage Commodity / parity capability
Fit No product fits; unique workflows Products fit 80%+ with configuration
Time to market Can wait Need it now
Total cost of ownership (5 years) Lower at our scale Lower including integration
Skills We can hire and retain the team Scarce skills
Risk & compliance We need full control Vendor certified (PCI, SOC 2) reduces our burden
Lock-in & exit Strategic dependency unacceptable Exit cost acceptable, data portable

TCO for build = development + infrastructure + maintenance (often 15–25% of initial build per year) + operations/on-call + security/compliance + opportunity cost of engineers. TCO for buy = licences/subscription (with growth) + implementation/integration + customization + vendor management + exit cost.

Result for the scenario: (a) partner with a card processor, (b) buy a fraud platform initially with in-house rules on top, (c) buy HR SaaS, (d) build the lending decision engine.

Example

[!FACT] Many large retailers use Shopify, Salesforce or SAP for commerce and CRM while building proprietary capabilities in pricing, supply chain and data, consistent with the build-for-differentiation principle.

CTO interview questions and model answers

The engineering team wants to build an internal tool that exists as SaaS. How do you decide?

Ask what is differentiated, compute 5-year TCO for both including maintenance and opportunity cost, assess fit and lock-in, run a time-boxed proof of concept of the best SaaS option, and record the decision in an ADR with revisit criteria.

When should you revisit a buy decision?

When scale makes licence costs exceed build costs, when the capability becomes differentiating, when the vendor's roadmap diverges, or when lock-in becomes a strategic risk.